← Back to the app

Validation with real aircraft

How close does the calculator get to real aircraft? Here existing aircraft are rebuilt with their published data and the program computes their performance with the same formulas used in the design process. Next to each result you see the published value and the difference.

At a glance

Cessna 172R Skyhawk

Single-engine piston · CS-23 — General aviation

Span
11.00 m
Wing area
16.17 m²
Max take-off mass
1111 kg
Power
119 kW
Stall speed, flaps up
Published94 km/h
Computed97 km/h
Difference+3.2 %
Stall speed, landing flaps
Published87 km/h
Computed80 km/h
Difference-7.8 %
Max level speed at sea level
Published228 km/h
Computed249 km/h
Difference+9.5 %
Cruise speed2438 m · 80 % power
Published226 km/h
Computed217 km/h
Difference-3.9 %
Max rate of climb at sea level
Published3.6 m/s
Computed5.0 m/s
Difference+38.2 %
Service ceiling
Published4115 m
Computed5967 m
Difference+45.0 %
Take-off ground run
Published288 m
Computed194 m
Difference-32.8 %
Take-off distance to 15 m (50 ft)
Published514 m
Computed321 m
Difference-37.5 %
Landing distance from 15 m (50 ft)
Published395 m
Computed294 m
Difference-25.5 %
Landing ground run
Published168 m
Computed152 m
Difference-9.6 %
Range with maximum fuel3048 m · 60 % power · 45 min reserve
Published1272 km
Computed1769 km
Difference+39.0 %
Empty mass (class II estimate, step 7)
Published743 kg
Computed674 kg
Difference-9.3 %

Mean absolute difference: 21.8 %.

What the comparison shows

  • Stall and cruise speed are close to the published values: wing area, mass and the typical maximum lift coefficients are consistent.
  • Rate of climb and service ceiling are still too high. The propeller thrust now drops at low speed (static thrust and interpolation of Gudmundsson), which almost halved the error on the rate of climb; the rest probably comes from the fixed-pitch propeller, which at climb speed does not let the engine reach its full power, and from the zero-lift drag.
  • Maximum speed is too high: with a fixed-pitch propeller the engine does not reach its full power at sea level, while the program uses the full power; the cooling drag of the engine is not included either (the wing struts are).
  • Range is too high: the program computes the best range (speed of maximum range, all usable fuel minus the reserve), the book flies at 60 % power, faster than the best-range speed.
  • Take-off and landing distances are too short. They come from the statistical regression of Roskam; the equation of motion of step 12 gives a take-off that is even shorter (about −38 % over 15 m), so the cause is not the method: probably the static thrust estimated for a fixed-pitch propeller is too high and the published distances follow a more conservative take-off technique.

Assumptions for the missing data

  • Wing: equivalent trapezoid with the span, tip chord and gross area of the book (root chord derived from them).
  • Fuselage width and height: not given by the book, values of the default configuration of the category.
  • Positions along the fuselage (wing, tail surfaces, engine, landing gear): from the default configuration of the category, not measured on the drawings.
  • Tail surfaces: total area from the book (fixed part + control surface), span and height from the default configuration.
  • Maximum lift coefficients: clean value typical of the category; take-off and landing values computed by step 6 (Raymer) with the flap type of the book and, where the book does not give them, the flap chord, span and deflections of the default configuration. Not derived from the published stall speeds.
  • Propeller efficiency, specific fuel consumption and power lapse with altitude: typical values of the category.
  • Wing struts: two, with the dimensions of a “Cessna-like” strut from an example in Gudmundsson (length 1.52 m, chord 0.10 m, t/c 0.2).
  • Usable fuel converted to mass with the avgas density of Roskam.

Diamond DA40D Diamond Star

Single-engine piston · CS-23 — General aviation

Span
11.94 m
Wing area
13.54 m²
Max take-off mass
1150 kg
Power
99 kW
Stall speed, flaps up
Published96 km/h
Computed108 km/h
Difference+12.6 %
Cruise speed3048 m · 70 % power
Published232 km/h
Computed198 km/h
Difference-14.5 %
Max rate of climb at sea level
Published2.8 m/s
Computed4.0 m/s
Difference+40.6 %
Take-off ground run
Published335 m
Computed326 m
Difference-2.6 %
Take-off distance to 15 m (50 ft)
Published630 m
Computed542 m
Difference-14.0 %
Landing distance from 15 m (50 ft)
Published750 m
Computed366 m
Difference-51.2 %
Landing ground run
Published288 m
Computed189 m
Difference-34.4 %
Empty mass (class II estimate, step 7)
Published735 kg
Computed682 kg
Difference-7.2 %

Mean absolute difference: 22.1 %.

What the comparison shows

  • Take-off ground run within 3 % and take-off distance to 15 m 14 % short (CS-23 regression of Roskam). The clean stall speed is 13 % too high: the slender wing with its Wortmann airfoil reaches a higher maximum lift than the typical value of the category used here.
  • Rate of climb 41 % too high, as for the other light aircraft: the zero-lift drag and the propeller efficiency are probably optimistic. Cruise at 70 % power at 3,050 m is 15 % slow: the turbocharged diesel keeps its power with altitude, while the program applies the lapse of a normally aspirated engine.
  • Landing distances much shorter than published (−51 % from 15 m, −34 % ground run): the published values of this aircraft are long for its weight, while the regression of Roskam describes average CS-23 aircraft. Class II empty mass within 7 %.

Assumptions for the missing data

  • Wing: span and gross area of the book with the taper ratio of the default configuration (root and tip chords not given).
  • Fuselage width and height: not given by the book, values of the default configuration of the category.
  • Positions along the fuselage (wing, tail surfaces, engine, landing gear): from the default configuration of the category, not measured on the drawings.
  • Tail surfaces: total area from the book (fixed part + control surface), span and height from the default configuration.
  • Maximum lift coefficients: clean value typical of the category; take-off and landing values computed by step 6 (Raymer) with the flap type of the book and, where the book does not give them, the flap chord, span and deflections of the default configuration. Not derived from the published stall speeds.
  • Propeller efficiency, specific fuel consumption and power lapse with altitude: typical values of the category.
  • Usable fuel converted to mass with the jet-fuel density of Roskam (diesel engine).
  • Airfoil: the Wortmann FX 63-144 section of the book is not modelled; a NACA 4414 of similar thickness and camber is used.

Beechcraft Bonanza G36

Single-engine piston · CS-23 — General aviation

Span
10.21 m
Wing area
16.80 m²
Max take-off mass
1655 kg
Power
224 kW
Stall speed, flaps up
Published126 km/h
Computed117 km/h
Difference-7.3 %
Stall speed, landing flaps
Published109 km/h
Computed96 km/h
Difference-12.2 %
Max rate of climb at sea level
Published6.3 m/s
Computed7.6 m/s
Difference+20.9 %
Service ceiling
Published5640 m
Computed6699 m
Difference+18.8 %
Landing distance from 15 m (50 ft)
Published442 m
Computed420 m
Difference-5.0 %
Landing ground run
Published290 m
Computed217 m
Difference-25.3 %
Empty mass (class II estimate, step 7)
Published1148 kg
Computed994 kg
Difference-13.5 %

Mean absolute difference: 14.7 %.

What the comparison shows

  • Stall speeds are below the published ones (−7 % clean, −12 % with flaps): the clean maximum lift coefficient (1.5, typical of the category) is probably too high for this wing. With flaps the program uses the single-slotted flaps of the book (step 6, Raymer), but with the flap chord and span of the default configuration, which the book does not give.
  • Rate of climb (+21 %) and ceiling (+19 %) are closer to the published values than for the Cessna 172R: the constant-speed propeller keeps the efficiency nearer to the typical value used by the program. The rest probably comes from the zero-lift drag and the propeller efficiency.
  • Landing distance from 15 m within 5 % (CS-23 regression of Roskam); the landing run is 25 % short.
  • Class II empty mass 13.5 % lower: retractable landing gear, six seats and the equipment of this aircraft are heavier than the statistical average of the formulas.

Assumptions for the missing data

  • Wing: equivalent trapezoid with the span, tip chord and gross area of the book (root chord derived from them).
  • Fuselage width and height: not given by the book, values of the default configuration of the category.
  • Positions along the fuselage (wing, tail surfaces, engine, landing gear): from the default configuration of the category, not measured on the drawings.
  • Tail surfaces: total area from the book (fixed part + control surface), span and height from the default configuration.
  • Maximum lift coefficients: clean value typical of the category; take-off and landing values computed by step 6 (Raymer) with the flap type of the book and, where the book does not give them, the flap chord, span and deflections of the default configuration. Not derived from the published stall speeds.
  • Propeller efficiency, specific fuel consumption and power lapse with altitude: typical values of the category.
  • Usable fuel converted to mass with the avgas density of Roskam.
  • Airfoil: the NACA 23016.5/23012 sections of the book (5-digit series) are not modelled; a NACA 2416 of similar thickness and camber is used for drag and zero-lift angle.

Beechcraft Baron 58

Twin-engine piston · CS-23 — General aviation

Span
11.53 m
Wing area
18.51 m²
Max take-off mass
2495 kg
Power
448 kW
Stall speed, flaps up
Published156 km/h
Computed137 km/h
Difference-12.2 %
Stall speed, landing flaps
Published139 km/h
Computed112 km/h
Difference-19.4 %
Max level speed at sea level
Published385 km/h
Computed421 km/h
Difference+9.2 %
Max rate of climb at sea level
Published8.6 m/s
Computed11.0 m/s
Difference+27.5 %
Service ceiling
Published6305 m
Computed7632 m
Difference+21.0 %
Landing distance from 15 m (50 ft)
Published747 m
Computed572 m
Difference-23.5 %
Landing ground run
Published396 m
Computed295 m
Difference-25.5 %
Empty mass (class II estimate, step 7)
Published1764 kg
Computed1704 kg
Difference-3.4 %

Mean absolute difference: 17.7 %.

What the comparison shows

  • Class II empty mass within 4 % and maximum level speed at sea level 9 % high: the program uses the full power of both engines with the typical propeller efficiency.
  • Stall speeds 12–19 % low: the typical maximum lift coefficients of the category are too high for this wing with NACA 230-series sections and two engine nacelles, which the CLmax estimate does not account for.
  • Rate of climb +28 % and service ceiling +21 %, the same trend as the single-engine aircraft (zero-lift drag and propeller efficiency); landing distances 24–26 % short (CS-23 regression of Roskam).

Assumptions for the missing data

  • Wing: equivalent trapezoid with the span, tip chord and gross area of the book (root chord derived from them).
  • Fuselage width and height: not given by the book, values of the default configuration of the category.
  • Positions along the fuselage (wing, tail surfaces, engine, landing gear): from the default configuration of the category, not measured on the drawings.
  • Tail surfaces: total area from the book (fixed part + control surface), span and height from the default configuration.
  • Maximum lift coefficients: clean value typical of the category; take-off and landing values computed by step 6 (Raymer) with the flap type of the book and, where the book does not give them, the flap chord, span and deflections of the default configuration. Not derived from the published stall speeds.
  • Propeller efficiency, specific fuel consumption and power lapse with altitude: typical values of the category.
  • Usable fuel converted to mass with the avgas density of Roskam.
  • Airfoil: the NACA 23015.5/23010.5 sections of the book (5-digit series) are not modelled; a NACA 2413 of similar mean thickness is used.

Pilatus PC-12/47

Single-engine turboprop · CS-23 — General aviation

Span
16.28 m
Wing area
25.81 m²
Max take-off mass
4740 kg
Power
895 kW
Stall speed, flaps up
Published170 km/h
Computed159 km/h
Difference-6.5 %
Stall speed, landing flaps
Published122 km/h
Computed132 km/h
Difference+7.8 %
Max rate of climb at sea level
Published8.0 m/s
Computed12.0 m/s
Difference+49.8 %
Take-off ground run
Published503 m
Computed321 m
Difference-36.3 %
Take-off distance to 15 m (50 ft)
Published808 m
Computed532 m
Difference-34.1 %
Landing distance from 15 m (50 ft)
Published558 m
Computed792 m
Difference+41.9 %
Landing ground run
Published288 m
Computed409 m
Difference+41.9 %
Empty mass (class II estimate, step 7)
Published2661 kg
Computed2105 kg
Difference-20.9 %

Mean absolute difference: 29.9 %.

What the comparison shows

  • Stall speeds within 8 %, with the Fowler flaps estimated in step 6.
  • Rate of climb +50 %: the program climbs with the 895 kW take-off rating and the power lapse of a piston engine, while the PT6A is flat-rated to 746 kW in the climb. Take-off distances 34–36 % short: the CS-23 regression of Roskam is built on light piston aircraft.
  • Landing distances 42 % long and Class II empty mass 21 % low: the regression does not use the reverse thrust of the reversible-pitch propeller, and the statistical formulas for general aviation do not include pressurisation, de-icing and the equipment of a turboprop business aircraft.

Assumptions for the missing data

  • Wing: span and gross area of the book with the taper ratio of the default configuration (root and tip chords not given).
  • Fuselage width and height: cabin interior of the book plus 10 cm of structure (assumption).
  • Positions along the fuselage (wing, tail surfaces, engine, landing gear): from the default configuration of the category, not measured on the drawings.
  • Maximum lift coefficients: clean value typical of the category; take-off and landing values computed by step 6 (Raymer) with the flap type of the book and, where the book does not give them, the flap chord, span and deflections of the default configuration. Not derived from the published stall speeds.
  • Propeller efficiency, specific fuel consumption and power lapse with altitude: typical values of the category.
  • Airfoil: the NASA GA(W)-1 / LS(1) sections of the book are not modelled; a NACA 2417 of similar thickness is used.
  • T-tail not modelled (horizontal tail on the fuselage); positions along the fuselage from the default configuration, scaled with the fuselage length.

Aircraft names and trademarks belong to their owners; this site has no affiliation with the manufacturers. The comparison is indicative and does not replace the official flight manual.