Cessna 172R Skyhawk
Single-engine piston · CS-23 — General aviation
- Span
- 11.00 m
- Wing area
- 16.17 m²
- Max take-off mass
- 1111 kg
- Power
- 119 kW
Mean absolute difference: 21.8 %.
What the comparison shows
- Stall and cruise speed are close to the published values: wing area, mass and the typical maximum lift coefficients are consistent.
- Rate of climb and service ceiling are still too high. The propeller thrust now drops at low speed (static thrust and interpolation of Gudmundsson), which almost halved the error on the rate of climb; the rest probably comes from the fixed-pitch propeller, which at climb speed does not let the engine reach its full power, and from the zero-lift drag.
- Maximum speed is too high: with a fixed-pitch propeller the engine does not reach its full power at sea level, while the program uses the full power; the cooling drag of the engine is not included either (the wing struts are).
- Range is too high: the program computes the best range (speed of maximum range, all usable fuel minus the reserve), the book flies at 60 % power, faster than the best-range speed.
- Take-off and landing distances are too short. They come from the statistical regression of Roskam; the equation of motion of step 12 gives a take-off that is even shorter (about −38 % over 15 m), so the cause is not the method: probably the static thrust estimated for a fixed-pitch propeller is too high and the published distances follow a more conservative take-off technique.
Assumptions for the missing data
- Wing: equivalent trapezoid with the span, tip chord and gross area of the book (root chord derived from them).
- Fuselage width and height: not given by the book, values of the default configuration of the category.
- Positions along the fuselage (wing, tail surfaces, engine, landing gear): from the default configuration of the category, not measured on the drawings.
- Tail surfaces: total area from the book (fixed part + control surface), span and height from the default configuration.
- Maximum lift coefficients: clean value typical of the category; take-off and landing values computed by step 6 (Raymer) with the flap type of the book and, where the book does not give them, the flap chord, span and deflections of the default configuration. Not derived from the published stall speeds.
- Propeller efficiency, specific fuel consumption and power lapse with altitude: typical values of the category.
- Wing struts: two, with the dimensions of a “Cessna-like” strut from an example in Gudmundsson (length 1.52 m, chord 0.10 m, t/c 0.2).
- Usable fuel converted to mass with the avgas density of Roskam.